Whats Wrong With My Spuds
For the second year running my maincrop potatoes (Maris Piper this year, Desiree last year) have produced an abundant crop. However when boiling it seems that all is well at first then suddenly they just disintegrate and turn to slop in seconds. Apparently we've had a wet summer but not here in Sheffield, so i have had to give them a good soaking a few times. Appearance wise they look fine and are good for baking and ok for chips (albeit very dry). This is the second year on my allotment which still has fairly poor soil (dry and a bit silty) so i was wondering if this is the problem. I have grown Desiree in the past in very clay soil with no problems at all. Some of the other allotment holders have had similar problems, though some were ok. Just wondering really if the problem is the soil or maybe lack of water. For some reason there were no flowers (or very few).....is this a symptom of something???
Views: 240
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Jan Willetts on -
The Edzell Blue that I grew did the same, discovered that they are better steamed. Nicola is similar, but just the outer skin breaks up. I read somewhere that you should put freshly dug potatoes into boiling water, not cold, to avoid overcooking.
-
Permalink Reply by Flighty on -
I rarely have problems boiling potatoes! Regardless of if they're whole or cut, with or without skins I bring them to the boil then turn the heat down so the water is just simmering. I do watch them and check for when they're ready as if they're left they'll probably go mushy.
A lot of people recommend steaming them.
I doubt that it's the soil, and I tend not to water mine except when it's very dry and then only occasionally. The lack of flowers is of no consequence as some varieties don't flower.
-
Permalink Reply by Gareth Bannister on -
I found this on the webternet:
Do-it-yourself Specific Gravity Test for Potatoes
Add 225gm table salt to 1775 gm water and stir until dissolved. The temperature should be around 20C. This produces a salt solution with a specific gravity of about 1.080.
Place the potatoes into the solution, one at a time. If they float, they will be good, firm boilers. If they sink, they will probably be mealy when boiled. These are high dry matter potatoes, and probably best steamed.
-
Permalink Reply by Debbie on -
Some varieties do that whatever you try but I only half boil mine, then pop into a dish and cover with tin foil to finish off. Just leave them to do their thing. Perfick!
-
Permalink Reply by Colin Robinson on -
is this a symptom of something???
It's just a symptom of boiling them too long. As Debbie says, some varieties just do that. Maris Piper make good chips but they only need a short boil or they disintegrate as you've discovered. The great thing about growing your own is that you can try dozens of different varieties that 'shoppers' never get to experience. Trouble is you have to treat them all differently :(
-
Permalink Reply by Malagrowther on -
Some potatoes just do that - Edzell Blue are notorious.
Home grown spuds need shorter cooking times than supermarket ones. I was brought up with the rule of thumb that potatoes need 15 minutes. I boil our current crop for 8 mins max.
Cook by adding cold water and heating rather than adding boiling water. There is a zone between 50 and 70 degrees C in which an enzyme is activated which alters the cell structure. (Calcium ions and pectins cross link cells making them more resilient at higher temperatures). "Persistent firmness" can be encouraged by preheating to the zone for 20 to 30 minutes before bringing to the boil. Got to admit I've never gone to that length to test the theory, but your spuds will spend more time in the zone if you heat them in cold not hot water!
-
Permalink Reply by Colin Dixon on -
Thanks to everyone for the advice. Guess the best thing for now is to treat them with kid gloves, and either be very watchfull or steam em.
-
Permalink Reply by Rob Duffin on -
I have the same problem, but it's usually because I'm not keeping an eye on them ;>) I try to steam them as well. Or it could just be I'm in Sheffield too. 'Wet summer' - LOL!
-
Permalink Reply by sweetpea lou on -
Terry who does the allotment slot on Jeremy Vine's programme on Radio 2 was asked this question on Friday. Apparently it is the high water content of the potato which means when it comes into contact with the extra water in the pan it turns to mush. He said he roasted any potatoes like this. You could also try steaming, maybe by not being submerged in water then will cook fine this way.
-
Permalink Reply by elaine rickett on -
Your problems sound like an exact replica of mine - no flowers, potatoes dry, foliage dying back prematurely. I have always grown Desiree usually with excellent results - not this year. I am sure the dry weather had something to do with it. My total harvest has been abyssmal.
-
Permalink Reply by Gareth Bannister on
-
I think the dry spell we had probably lead to many potatoes having a higher dry matter content then usual this year. Just as an aside, 'Mayan Gold' turn to mush if boiled but are delicious otherwise.
-
Permalink Reply by Sue Gollop on -
I find this happens to maincrop potatoes if I cook them very freshly dug; 3 weeks + later after being stored they are fine but they still need cooking for less time than you might expect, and straight into boiling water not from cold, then turn down immediately so the water is barely moving.
Our Sponsor
Our Badge
Most Active Members
| 1 |
elaine rickett |
| 2 |
David Ford |
| 3 |
Mark Willis |
| 4 |
pete |
| 5 |
Robert |
| 6 |
Kamila Przekop |
| 7 |
Darren O |
| 8 |
steve webster |
| 9 |
Laila Noort |
| 10 |
Colin Robinson |
Groups
Events
Illustrations By...
© 2013 Created by Stephen Shirley.
